The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search

Phuket tourists split over virgin beaches: Poll

Phuket tourists split over virgin beaches: Poll

PHUKET: The recent revelation by Phuket Governor Chockchai Dejamornthan that he will start taking steps to have all beaches in Phuket cleared of vendors and returned to “virgin” status has received a mixed reaction among expats and foreign visitors in an online poll by The Phuket News.

By The Phuket News

Monday 14 November 2016, 10:09AM

More than 40% of respondents called for beach vendors to be allowed to return. Photo: The Phuket News / file

More than 40% of respondents called for beach vendors to be allowed to return. Photo: The Phuket News / file

Currently, the “10% zones” are the last bastions where vendors may work at selected beaches in Phuket, and were introduced by Phuket’s previous Governor, Chamroen Tipayapongtada.

However, the “beach rules” in Phuket specifically apply only in Phuket. The 10% rule does not apply anywhere else in Thailand, not even in Khao Lak, just one hour’s drive north of Phuket, or even on Phi Phi or elsewhere in across the bay in Krabi.

Gov Chockchai last month explained that his understanding was that local authorities had no legal right to allow any vendors on the beaches, and that he would have them removed.

To this, The Phuket News asked readers in an online poll, “Do you support Gov Chockchai’s plan to clear Phuket’s beaches of all vendors?”

The poll, which ran for two weeks, concluded at midnight last night as Phuket begins to enter its annual tourism high season.

Of note, 80% of respondents to the poll were expats or foreign visitors to Phuket.

Only 14% agreed with Gov Chockchai’s stance, voting “Yes, all beaches in Phuket should be clear of all vendors.”

QSI International School Phuket

However, a further 34% called for the Governor to “clear the beaches of vendors, but allow tourists to bring their own sun loungers.”

In contrast, 41% of respondents called for a return to Phuket’s past, voting, “No, allow vendors back on the beaches, which worked well for tourists for years.”

The current status of allowing vendors to occupy 10% of the beach at selected beaches gained the least support, with 12% of respondents voting, “No, leave the ‘10% rule’ in place – it is the best solution so far.”

To see the full poll results, click here.

If your preferred response was not available, feel free to express your opinion in the comments section below.

To see the results of our previous poll, which asked, “Is the Thai lottery worth playing?”, click here.

If you have a suggestion for a poll, email with “Poll suggestion” in the Subject line.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.


Kurt | 01 January 2017 - 13:02:06

@ Phuket beaches:  Please, be patient. The Governor promised to take steps to clear all Phuket beaches of vendors.
Just be patient, The Governor is just still warming up to start to executive this heavy task.
Give him time!

Kurt | 01 January 2017 - 12:56:32

@ Jome, Hahaha, You describe a Singapore scene.!
Yes, the scene in S'pore attracts indeed quality tourists, as we all know.
As you describe, Phuket has many years a lot of work to do first before quality tourist will favor Phuket ( again).

Jome | 01 January 2017 - 10:24:03

Why would Phuket need Virgin Beaches or spend effort or money for the beaches at all????
This would be for the cheapo touris who steal their daily sandwich ration at the hotel breakfast buffet and buy a bottle of water at super cheap for the beach.......
Phuket wants quality tourists!!
Phuket needs more shopping malls with artificial blue lagoons and artificial palm trees,gem palaces and duty f...

Phuket beaches | 31 December 2016 - 12:33:04

How about that fact they are allowing beach vendors to move the towels of swimmers ( Who don't pay ( so they can replace them with beach mats and umbrellas for paying customers?

This happened to me at Surin Beach on Wednesday.

When i was swimming, i saw the beach vendor dragging my towel 10 metres down the beach and then replacing the area with a mat and umbrella for 2 paying customers.

Kurt | 30 December 2016 - 11:49:43

It is very simple. What was not virgin anymore for many years (Phuket beaches), you can't go back in time and make it virgin again.
Once not a virgin anymore, never a virgin again.

Thai authorities have to come up with another concept to promote the Phuket jewels, the beaches, but when they want to attract foreign tourists again, they have to think and work out 'foreign'.

yvonne | 29 December 2016 - 19:58:19

Mr Eric de Kegel, this is not your Europe! This is Thailand of the Thai people first and foremost. The beaches are for everyone, Rich and Poor and first and foremost should be the Thai citizens.Your European ideas of creating here another foreign type of French Riviera with a "monopoly by large chain hotels", many of them also owned by "foreign groups" not  just Thais, (possibl...

Foot | 17 December 2016 - 16:03:16

To skip.  2 1/2 years ago the governor said the beach attractions - chairs, umbrellas, high season bars, restaurants, and vendors were eliminated because the government couldn't control the various mafias involved.  So, instead of stepping up law enforcement, it was decided to eliminate these attractions.  I don't know about the taxes being paid, them, but, there is much less income now w...

Kurt | 16 November 2016 - 12:57:39

'Virgin Beaches' Phuket means:

No...: No chairs, no vendors, no beach cleaning, not waste water management.
YES:.  :Illegal chairs + umbrella's, illegal vendors, and free release of waste water from hotels, restaurants, laundries, including urine and faeces.

What was illegal until 2.5 years ago and banned, is back!
10% zones are by Governor declared 'unlawful', but not ...

skip | 15 November 2016 - 17:47:42

the reason the deck chairs and umbrellas were removed was the management at the te****aan were pocketing the money from the leasing of the areas on the beach. not one baht was invested in infrastructure and not one bant was paid in tax. the rich got richer and the poor got the picture.the money was said to be 150 mi***on baht ++ annualy on pa***g beach alone.unfortunately the tourists are not happ...

Ed Sanders | 15 November 2016 - 16:23:03

Nice spiel for the hotel industry erik dekegel...just a selfish rant how the poor people need to make money, and how it is easy to organize and regulate.  Where in Phuket have you spent the last 13 years? Maybe you forgot about these beautiful beaches lined with 5 or more jam-packed rows of tacky plastic beds with crusty rubber mats, with punk thugs kicking sand in peoples faces because they just ...

Concerned | 15 November 2016 - 08:55:37

Tourist needs 
Most Tourists come to Phuket from the cold part of the world because of the sunny warm climate, beaches and the sea…
In order to have a good holiday vacation it is necessary to provide them with proper clean Beach Faculties, Toilets, Beach Chairs, Sun Umbrellas, and Food Drinks etc.
if you over 50 and have worked you whole live you are perhaps in tile for a little comfort to li...

eric dekegel | 14 November 2016 - 19:20:33

Dear Nasa123, a little bit a pitty you not come out with your real name, I pay here taxes for 13 years,workpermit and visa for 13 years and get nothing back as farang but working in the hotelbusiness as many families on the island it is not difficult to organize the beaches, you do like in europe, you rent them out by sqm by year or 6 months
a part and let them sign what they can sale or rent out...

Nasa123 | 14 November 2016 - 15:18:46

Dear eric dekegel@  And take this to Governor in Phuket :

Nasa123 | 14 November 2016 - 15:13:58

eric dekegel @ And which vendor on the beaches pay Tax in Phuket I can tell you 0 vendors, jet ski ,food every thing.Thake the all  from the beaches in Phuket.

Nasa123 | 14 November 2016 - 15:08:48

eric dekegel@ Taxpayer in Phuket ?? tell me ho pay tax in Phuket, my wife pay tax every mount but in Mars /April she go to Tax office in Chalong and get all Tax money back.

Foot | 14 November 2016 - 15:01:47

I've said for the last few years that tourists come to Phuket for 3 reasons - culture, beach, and nightlife (good and bad).
If Phuket continues to restrict the beach's attraction by not having chairs, umbrellas, vendors, bars and restaurants, tourists will go elsewhere where they are welcomed.  
The "virgin beach" supporters could care less about tourism and the income it gener...

Nasa123 | 14 November 2016 - 13:11:39

I think you ned to take this Poll again, 98% off my voting are wrong ? I voting many time every day on: Yes, clear the beaches of vendors, but allow tourists to bring their own sun loungers.But my voting all the time still 98% go to: No, allow vendors back on the beaches, which worked well for tourists for years. It`s not BIG deal but right most be right, and whay I now that are a secret. I am acc...

eric dekegel | 14 November 2016 - 11:12:31

I hope that the newspaper will have the courage to bring this poll personally to the governor so maybe he will understand whats going on on the island.And what his taxpayers think about!I even want to join and explain him how to organize as it is even not solving a problem.And I am sure all hoteliers would be happy to join and to give him the result of course taken with a nice picture of him the p...


Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
COVID-19 and tourism: Can domestic travel address the slump in emerging markets?

The short answer is no. Of course it can't and it would be disingenuous to suggest so. ...(Read More)

Lockdown eased from Monday

Ok so will the beaches be allowed to open for swimming , diving etc ...(Read More)

Thailand aiming for complete end to lockdown on July 1: NSC Chief

It’s not clear to me, according to this last decree International travels will be allowed again fr...(Read More)

As annual rains arrive, Phuket health chief issues dengue warning

Dr Thanit should starts 'precaution' measures herself first. She forgot to 'order' d...(Read More)

Thailand aiming for complete end to lockdown on July 1: NSC Chief

@harald: so you are obviously a subject matter expert? is life so boring that dark conspiration th...(Read More)

Lockdown eased from Monday

What's missing yet again? Airport and beaches....(Read More)

Lockdown eased from Monday

What about the beaches? The Bangkok Post reports you can Ballroom Dance, but a swim in the ocean???...(Read More)