Login | Create Account Poll Currency Weather Facebook Youtube Search

Phuket Marine Chief oblique on Phoenix dereliction of duty charges, assures ‘no illegal tour boats’

PHUKET: The Acting Chief of the Phuket Marine Office, Wiwat Chitchertwong, was silent yesterday (Dec 18) on questions about marine officials being prosecuted for dereliction of duty for allowing the tour boat Phoenix to put to sea, in the wake of the investigation into the Phoenix sinking on July 5, killing 47 Chinese tourists.

By Tanyaluk Sakoot

Wednesday 19 December 2018, 11:07AM

The ’Phoenix’ is pictured at the Rattanachai Shipyard, east of Phuket Town, late last month. Photo: Supplied

The ’Phoenix’ is pictured at the Rattanachai Shipyard, east of Phuket Town, late last month. Photo: Supplied

Although it has already been confirmed that other boats also built in Phuket have the same design as the Phoenix, Mr Wiwat yesterday assured that no boats with illegal ‘substandard’ designs were still operating among the Phuket tour boat fleet.

Mr Wiwat’s reaction followed Immigration Bureau chief Pol Lt Gen Surachate Hakparn on Monday (Dec 17) publicly revealing that the Phoenix was substandard and illegally approved, and that officials and others connected with the July 5 tragedy will lose their jobs.

“Chinese and German specialists agree that the boat was substandard… It was not built at a shipyard but at a machine shop. Police have laid down charges during the interrogation process. Phuket marine officials were prosecuted for dereliction of duty,” he said. (See story here.)

Gen Surachate, who previously served as Deputy Commander of the national Tourist Police, has been tasked with leading the investigation into the Phoenix tragedy, along with Royal Thai Police Deputy Commander Lt Gen Rungroj Sangkram. (See story here.)

Mr Wiwat yesterday assured,“All designs of boats (in operation in Thailand) are approved by the Ship Standard Registration Bureau of the Marine Department. The same applies for all designs, including the design for the Phoenix.

“We inspected more than 1,000 boats operating from ports (and piers) in Phuket after the July 5 disaster. We found some boats did not match their designs, and their owners were ordered to have them corrected. They have been taken out of service until they have undergone reworking at shipyards,” he said.

“Marine Department officials from (the Ship Standard Registration Bureau) in Bangkok will come to check the boats again to make sure they meet safety standards. If they pass, they will be approved for use by the Marine Department officials from Bangkok and the Phuket Marine Office,” he added.

Mr Wiwat declined to specify how many boats had been ordered to be rectified or which shipyards were carrying out the “redesigns”. He just said, “In Phuket province.”

“There are no illegal boats in Phuket for which the owners will be charged. I have ordered them to have the boats fixed already. Currently, there are no boats (in operation) that do not meet the standards required,” Mr Wiwat repeated.

Mr Wiwat declined to confirm or deny whether any officials at the Phuket Marine Office were involved in approving the Phoenix to put to sea with tourists on board.


“Some Marine Department officials who are concerned with the Phoenix boat are being questioned by investigators. I don’t know any more details,” he said.

“The investigation of the Phoenix disaster is being carried out by the Royal Thai Police, as Gen Surachate Hakparn revealed to the press (on Monday). I don’t disagree with what he said, but I am waiting for official confirmation by documents, not just words,” Mr Wiwat added.

Of note, Mr Wiwat was not the Chief of the Phuket Marine Office at the time of the Phoenix disaster on July 5. He was installed as the Acting Director from his post as the Chief of the Ayutthaya Marine Office, a position he still officially retains.

The Phuket Marine Chief on July 5 was Surat Sirisaiyat, who was transferred immediately after the disaster to the post of Acting Chief of the Ayutthaya Marine Office, where he is expected to remain while the investigation continues.

Mr Surat was last in Phuket on Nov 18 to be present in person for the official handover of the Phoenix wreck to police investigators when the boat was pulled up onto stands on the hardstand at the Ratanachai shipyard on the east side of Phuket Town.

“Now this is done my responsibility with this boat has concluded as it is no longer in the water,” Mr Surat told The Phuket News that afternoon in a brief conversation by phone.

“I have officially transferred responsibility of the boat over to the Royal Thai Police investigation team. Now it is their job to investigate the Phoenix further,” he said.

Mr Surat declined to comment further about the Phoenix, which was operating tours for Chinese tourists while he was the Phuket Marine Chief.

“I have done my job already. I have no comment about the Phoenix. Now, I am on the way back to the Ayutthaya Marine Office,” he said before the conversation was terminated.



Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

Comments Here:
Comments Left:
# Characters

Uncle | 21 December 2018 - 09:39:29

20 only ! You bet there are bundles more boats used for tourists that are in as bad - or worse conditions and shape than Phoenix.  Good luck to any tourist, daring to venture out with / on many of these crappy, unsafe boats and - as bad - totally unqualified so-called "crew" members, who never should be allowed behind the control of these boats.

Kurt | 21 December 2018 - 08:55:18

Seeing the Phoenix Photo,  poor Phoenix, first time in her 'life' now being on a real proper shipyard. Wish she was built on a proper shipyard, with a Classification Bureau guiding her building in the past. So much blame on thai authorities.  But, well, it was just a boat for tourists, not a party boat for Sino-Thai His-So's.

Kurt | 21 December 2018 - 08:45:22

Yes, in Rawai, close to Shell Museum, a walled compound with many tourist speed boats!  A excellent opportunity for relevant authorities to go there, inspect the boats, after safety inspection decide yes/no or these boats are allowed to sail again. With marine licensed boatmen of course. Under responsibility 
of the Phuket Marine Office. What block authorities until now to do these inspections?

Timothy | 20 December 2018 - 09:42:19

Auttthaya Marine Office? Is he now in charge of inspecting the boats in the floating market?  

zib | 20 December 2018 - 00:21:23

Is this why there are 20 speedboats for sale suddenly on Viset road in Rawai? Or is that because of the low tourist numbers..

Asterix | 19 December 2018 - 15:50:14

ThePhuketNews wrote: Phuket Marine Chief oblique on Phoenix dereliction of duty charges, assures ‘no illegal tour boats’

The message from officials is clear:
- back-off, none of your business!

Discover Thainess | 19 December 2018 - 14:44:07

Head ..... sand ...... buried
Fingers well and truly crossed!

Fascinated | 19 December 2018 - 12:46:14

'Ayutthaya Marine Office'- that really is creating jobs for the boys!

Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
In Big Joke saga, border patrol boss gets last laugh

Perhaps a part time laugh? The moment he becomes original in handling matters ( which is needed to l...(Read More)

Italians, boat crew and guide all arrested for fishing in national park

As a foreigner, you expect going out with thai boat captain and a thai fishing guide for fishing tha...(Read More)

Patong Police call for calm after foreigner outburst over motorbike collision goes viral

Not surprised. The standards of tourists Thailand lets in nowadays is dismal. Just take the money do...(Read More)

Italians, boat crew and guide all arrested for fishing in national park

The fish caught were disposed of in a hole in the ground. Hahahaha. Yeah, right. Dinner for the park...(Read More)

Inspectors suspect foul play from Patong resorts

Inspections should be done without announcing that they go to inspect. Do 'surprise inspections&...(Read More)

Australian stabbed 12 times trying to protect Thai woman

Anyone who believes you can stab someone 12 times in "self-defense" is overdue for a spell...(Read More)

Italians, boat crew and guide all arrested for fishing in national park

Burn the boat as well. nearly 50 kg fish catched by only 2 sportfishers in a nationalpark?? Fishing ...(Read More)

King cobra female caught in Patong, 30 eggs missing from nest

Should have brought the eggs to the serial poster.As he likes to sit down,he could carefully hatch t...(Read More)

Boy, 14, killed as Phuket suffers worst Songkran road safety record in years

Wiesel, it is not about our minds. It is about the 'after' of accidents. People not able to ...(Read More)

Patong Police call for calm after foreigner outburst over motorbike collision goes viral

Haha, very funny outcome. Pay 30,000 thb on forehand? Show me the costs of motorbike repair & m...(Read More)