THE PAVILIONS PHUKET BRITISH INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, PHUKET
THE PAVILIONS PHUKET BRITISH INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, PHUKET Kata Rocks

Monsanto’s Roundup weedkiller contributed to US man’s cancer: jury

CALIFORNIA: The weedkiller Roundup was a “substantial factor” in the cancer of a US man who developed a lump in his throat after decades of spraying his garden – the second major legal defeat to agrochemical giant Monsanto in a year.


By AFP

Thursday 21 March 2019, 09:04AM


The verdict was the second major defeat in US courts for Monsanto in cases related to its Roundup weed killer within the space of a year. Photo: AFP

The verdict was the second major defeat in US courts for Monsanto in cases related to its Roundup weed killer within the space of a year. Photo: AFP

Edwin Hardeman, 70, treated his property in Sonoma County, California, regularly with the herbicide from 1980 to 2012 and was eventually diagnosed with non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma.

His lawyers Aimee Wagstaff and Jennifer Moore said in a joint statement their client was “pleased” with the decision.

“Now we can focus on the evidence that Monsanto has not taken a responsible, objective approach to the safety of Roundup,” they added.

“Instead, it is clear from Monsanto’s actions that it does not particularly care whether its product is, in fact, giving people cancer, focusing instead on manipulating public opinion and undermining anyone who raises genuine and legitimate concerns about the issue.”

Jurors had been asked to decide whether the ingredient glyphosate – the world’s most widely-used herbicide that has long been linked to cancer by environmentalists – was a “substantial factor” in Hardeman’s condition.

Hardeman and his lawyers hugged as the jury announced its decision, which came after a week of deliberations and follows a groundbreaking state-level trial last year brought by another plaintiff with the same condition as Hardeman.

The trial now moves to phase two – deciding whether Monsanto’s conduct makes it liable.

“We look forward to presenting this evidence to the jury and holding Monsanto accountable for its bad conduct,” Hardeman’s legal team added.

Monsanto, which has sold Roundup worldwide for more than 40 years, contends that scores of studies show the products are not dangerous if properly used.

The case is the first in US federal court on the alleged cancer risk posed by Roundup and will be seen as a test case, with thousands of other similar lawsuits already underway in the United States.

It follows the groundbreaking state trial last year brought by school groundskeeper Dewayne “Lee” Johnson.

In August, California jurors unanimously found that Monsanto acted with “malice” and that its glyphosate weedkillers Roundup and Ranger Pro substantially contributed to Johnson’s terminal illness.

Thailand Property Awards - Asia Property Awards

Monsanto was initially ordered to pay $289 million (B9.17 billion) to Johnson, who has two young sons and is in the end stages of his cancer before the damages were reduced to $78.5 million (B2.5 billion.) Germany’s Bayer, which bought Monsanto last year, filed an appeal.

Hardeman testified that he sprayed Roundup on his property on the outskirts of San Francisco to get rid of poison ivy, which causes an irritating, sometimes painful rash.

Monsanto has argued that Roundup was not to blame for Hardeman’s cancer, citing his age – 66 when he was diagnosed – and the complicating factor that he suffered from Hepatitis C.

Hardeman’s lawyers countered that as he had been cured of Hepatitis C, it could not have been a factor in his development of non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma.

One of the experts called by Hardeman’s team suggested that Roundup is even more dangerous than glyphosate on its own, because of additives in the weed killer.

“Look at all the studies, all the data,” Hardeman’s lead attorney Aimee Wagstaff told the jury. “Studies are pieces of a puzzle you have to put together.”

Unlike the US Environmental Protection Agency, the International Agency for Research on Cancer – which is part of the World Health Organization – has listed glyphosate as “probably carcinogenic.”

Bayer expressed disappointment with the decision but maintained that the science confirmed that glyphosate-based herbicides do not cause cancer.

On Feb 13, Thailand's Pharmacy Council Assoc Prof Jiraporn Limpananont released a statement calling for a ban on glyphosate as well as paraquat and chlorpyrifos.

She said the three chemicals were extremely poisonous. A few teaspoons of paraquat were lethal. Researchers had found paraquat contamination in the blood of pregnant women, umbilical cords, meconium (a newborn’s faeces), water, plants and food.

Fifty-three countries had already banned its use, including the biggest producer of paraquat, China, she said. (See story here.)

However,  on Feb 14 the national committee on hazardous substances rejected the request to ban the use of the three chemicals. (See story here.)

 

 

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

Comments Here:
Comments Left:
# Characters
Username:
Password:
E-mail:
Security:

Be the first to comment.

Have a news tip-off? Click here

 

Phuket community
Man charged after deadly head-on collision

Belt and Airbag would be helpful. R.I.P....(Read More)


Master water plan given green light

Nice, that 20 years '4 pillar' thing. A lot of work granted for office workers. The Third Pi...(Read More)


No animal cruelty at Phuket Zoo, say officials

As long as MNRE, DLD, Wild Life Edcation Centres, thai Vets and Zoo managers think it is normal to h...(Read More)


Fast & Furious 9 to take on Phuket roads

Mr Wiesel, 1: I didn't say I have a problem. 2: You not understand that other people could still...(Read More)


No animal cruelty at Phuket Zoo, say officials

Were there any blood tests done, a toxicology report should be available for all to see,a visual che...(Read More)


Fast & Furious 9 to take on Phuket roads

Sorry Mr. Kurt but i dont understand your problem because i have my own pump and dont have problems ...(Read More)


Fast & Furious 9 to take on Phuket roads

Sorry mr Wiesel. In Thailand is a lot of 'planning-talks' happening . After that it stops, i...(Read More)


No animal cruelty at Phuket Zoo, say officials

Herein lies the problem. The officials that do the inspections are either paid for their favorable r...(Read More)


Fast & Furious 9 to take on Phuket roads

As if there aren't enough fast and furious drivers already on the roads in Phuket, now to glorif...(Read More)