THE PAVILIONS PHUKET BRITISH INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, PHUKET Kata Rocks
Login | Create Account Poll Currency Weather Facebook Youtube Search

Hanks and Eckhardt play it safe in ‘Sully’

As its title suggests, Sully is squarely focussed on one person, Capt Chesley “Sully” Sullenberger (played by a silver-haired Tom Hanks), the US Airways pilot who famously ditched a commercial airliner on New York’s Hudson River in 2009, saving the lives of all 155 people on board.


By Mark Knowles

Saturday 1 October 2016, 02:00PM


Aaron Eckhart and Tom Hanks as pilots Chesley Sullenberger and Jeffrey Skiles in ‘Sully’. Photo: Warner Bros

Aaron Eckhart and Tom Hanks as pilots Chesley Sullenberger and Jeffrey Skiles in ‘Sully’. Photo: Warner Bros

Because the story the movie is based on is true and received worldwide press coverage, Sully is a sort of disaster movie – but without the disaster. We already know that everyone survives, and so it seems to struggle to find the dramatic tension integral to the genre. In fact, no spoiler alerts are needed in this review because you already know what happens.

In contradiction to the audience’s foreknowledge, the opening scene shows the stricken flight losing altitude as it weaves through the New York skyline and crashes into a skyscraper – before Sully wakes, startled, to show us it was a dream. This imagined disaster seems like a cheap trick by Director Clint Eastwood, who tries to ramp up tension by withholding a blow-by-blow account of the actual event until the movie’s finale. Instead, repeatedly teasing us with Sully’s imagined visions of just how badly it could have been.

Eastwood is, for the most part, interested in the investigation Sully and his co-pilot Jeffrey Skiles (played solidly by a moustachioed Aaron Eckhart) endure after the landing. The officious head bureaucrat of the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) (played by a smirking Mike O’Malley) seems implausibly hell-bent on taking our hero Sully down, accusing him of errors in judgement and even asking if he is having trouble at home.

This contrasts sharply with the reaction of the public we are shown – a cab driver congratulates him, random strangers hug him, and he is lauded on national television. Further attempts to increase dramatic tension come from repeated phone calls to his wife Lorraine (played competently by Laura Linney, who isn’t given much work) that touch on the couple’s financial troubles, which could lead to ruin if Sully is stripped of his wings by the NTSB.

Finally, we are given the full sequence of events that led to the landing on the Hudson, and here Eastwood delivers. It is a claustrophobic and genuinely scary portrayal of the event from both the passengers’ and pilots’ views. The special effects are simple and realistic to the point that you feel as though you are experiencing the real thing.

BRITISH INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, PHUKET

The culmination of the film is the public NTSB hearing in which Sully and his co-pilot have to defend their actions in the face of computer simulations that say they could have turned the plane around to land safely at La Guardia Airport.

Hanks delivers his impassioned speech on how computer simulations can’t account for the “human factor” and demands that more time be given to account for human decision making in the face of an unprecedented set of circumstances. Once re-calculated to account for reaction time, the simulations fail to land safely, and the NTSB board unanimously declare him a hero.

Though it’s competently directed – as you would expect from veteran film-maker Eastwood – it seems he could have picked a story with more mystery about the outcome. Here, Eastwood (who is known for his support of the small-government championing Republican party) is forced to make a straw man of the NTSB before knocking it over with barely a whimper.

Tom Hanks, who specialises in playing the stoic, work-a-day every-man cum hero (think of his recent turns in Captain Phillips and Bridge of Spies) is a safe pair of hands for Eastwood. Although convincing and likeable as ever, Hanks himself seems to be in autopilot mode with this latest role and it would be interesting to see him play a role with a bit more of a dramatic range.

 

 

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

Comments Here:
Comments Left:
# Characters
Username:
Password:
E-mail:
Security:

Christy Sweet | 02 October 2016 - 11:30:39

Good thing  they weren't One-Two Go pilots, who apparently threw up their arms in reverence to their  maker instead of flying the plane. 

Have a news tip-off? Click here

 

Phuket community
B1bn earmarked to improve road safety around schools

The picture says it all. 3 kids on a bike with no helmets and presumably no license (they don't ...(Read More)


Taxi driver charged after collision with motorbike leaves man, 74, dead

Way to set an example and actually improve road safety RTP... not. Spurious charges like this only s...(Read More)


Dogs rounded up at Ao Nang as PM visits Finnish boy dog-attack victim in hospital

Whatever the condition of more than 20 dogs is, they should never be allowed to be again at the beac...(Read More)


B1bn earmarked to improve road safety around schools

See the photo: 3 thai girls on 1 motorbike, no helmets, probably without driving license. And talki...(Read More)


Doubts on pot use linger over amended drug law

Well, a lot of tumbling new rules/laws/bla bla's. contradicting in everything, so, nothing will...(Read More)


Taxi driver charged after collision with motorbike leaves man, 74, dead

Correct application of the law. If you're too lazy to look at the road and what you or others i...(Read More)


Phuket health officials, police unite to enforce Makha Bucha alcohol ban

Dek, you are always talking about how you don't want Thailand to be a Nanny state. Now you are p...(Read More)


Finnish boy, 5, attacked by stray dogs at Ao Nang, Krabi

When will the Thai government stop taking orders from other governments and foreign organizations su...(Read More)


German expat gets eight years jail for slaying Phuket girlfriend

8 Years? You call that justice? I think a bullet in the back of the head would have been a more a...(Read More)


Finnish boy, 5, attacked by stray dogs at Ao Nang, Krabi

Dek, your comment makes no sense. Snakes not attack people when they are not provocated and feel the...(Read More)